Selecting the right carbon fibre bike frame

Robert Orgera wants to buy himself a carbon frame for his birthday, but he wants some advice on which frame would suit his riding style and needs. This is what we think:

Question:
I am looking to buy a new road bike for my 60th birthday, I have an ancient Trek 2300 with a lugged aluminium/carbon fibre tube frame, upgraded with 1997 vintage Dura ace components. I would like to get a carbon fibre frame with a more comfortable frame geometry given my age and the relaxed road riding I will be doing. If there is not much difference in frame geometry between manufacturers I would probably opt for a nicely equipped close out model or a less prestigious brand with a great component package to keep the price around 3K. But if there are certain frames that would provide a more comfortable ride and good handling I will spend more money if need be.

Hi Robert.

Happy Birthday when it comes Robert, and a carbon frame is a great present to your self.

You ask for our suggestions of a carbon frame with a more relaxed position, this quite simple as both Trek and Specialized have fit systems for a more up-right and relaxed position, here are the details:

Trek:

The Trek 6 series has three geometry set-ups from flat back to up-right comfort. The H1 geometry is for the fit rider that is looking for an aero position and can get low on the bike with a flexible spine and pelvic rotation; this is for a race position.

The H2 Geometry is an in-between the full on race position and a more relaxed ride. The H2 frame will feel similar to the H1, but with a slightly higher hand position to give you less strain on the neck and on the lower back without the use of a high angle stem or a long steerer with ugly spacers.

Then the H3 geometry is for the rider who wants the class and style of a Tour winning bike, but with comfort. The H3 set-up has a high front end and with a little bit of juggling with tube length and frame angles; Trek have a comfortable yet lively frame that would suit someone without the suppleness of a pro racer and has increased stability.

Specialized:

The other North American bike giant, Specialized has their Endurance Road range which is similar to the Trek system with a higher handle bar position. The Roubaix has the added advantage of Zertz inserts to dampen any road rumble and if you also go for the S-Works FACT carbon Pave seat post you will have full comfort. Specialized also have their Body Geometry Fit system where your body and cycling history is taken into consideration for comfort and proper bike fit.

Any of these frames with your choice of equipment would suit you well and for fill all your needs. You could shop around to find a “last year’s” model at a good price, but you will find that the popular sizes will have sold out. Good luck Robert!