Bike Cycling Reviews

How Heavy are our Testers?

By Alastair Hamilton
© copyright by bikecyclingreviews.com

Richard wants more information on our bike testers are he wants to know if we can put them through their paces. Our test riders are not as heavy as Richard but we do give all our equipment a thorough testing over many different terrains. Here are the details

Question: What is the weight and experience of the tester? It is very important to tell the reader the weight of the test rider. I am a large guy and am so tired of a 150 lbs man/woman telling me about products that are weight sensitive, i.e. wheels, frames, cranks, handlebars, seats, etc. Good, experienced heavy riders, those over 200 lbs, are actually better testers because they stress the new products much more so than smaller riders. Any new product brought to market by a large national company will more than likely meet the expectations of small riders because the tester does not have the time to adequately test or stress the product. However, if you let someone who is experienced and heavy (225 lbs) then he will almost immediately note the problems, the short comings, the benefits of the new product. Your analysis of the Roval Star wheels is a perfect example. I have been trying for 10 yrs to find a good wheel set. I live in a small town and weight 245 lbs.
I can't find anyone who can help me so, in turn; I have spent $100s on testing. Your review means nothing unless I know the weight and experience of the tester.

Hi Richard,

You need clarity on the size, weight and experience of our test riders, well none of them are over 200 lbs, but all are experienced riders who have raced at a fairly high level in road races, time trials, track, mountain bike and one of us has been riding Triathlon recently.

Carbon Roval

Our two heaviest riders have been using both pairs of Roval wheels over six months and apart from the retaining nuts on the rear axle coming loose on one pair there have been no problems. To readjust the axle only took seconds, so it wasn't a big deal.

Roval E5

We have tested both pairs of Roval wheels over many different road conditions over the six months and they have faired very well, we think the Roval Fusee E5 wheel set performs better and are lighter than the Star wheels. As the E5 wheels are lighter they are probably not the best for you, the Star wheels are stiffer, heavier and to some degree stronger.

I hope this clarifies things for you Richard?

Roval Star

Comment Script

Comments

Name
E-mail (Will not appear online)
Title
Comment

How to submit your Cycling Question?

Ask any question you may have about bike parts, accessories, clothing or training and let our team of experts help you.

Simply Click here to post your question, we will reply on the website shortly ..

Free Ebook

Signup today and we will notify you of new articles by email.

As a gift, we will also send you a free electronic copy of the Samuel Mascarell's & Alastair Hamilton's book, "Bicycle Adjustment Secrets ."
Download

Recommended Resources
Most Popular Posts

Cycle Training Mistakes
Training Plans and Programs
Polar S725x
Cycling Jerseys
Triahtlon Shoes
Cycling Shorts
Pro-Cycling Clothes
Italy Bike Tour
Sportive Fondos
Vitamins & Supplements
 
Recent Posts
The New Base Cycling Training eBook
Shimano Dura Ace 7850 Carbon Wheels
Which Chain Ring to Use?
A Campagnolo Problem
How Good are the Wheels on
27 inch, The Same as 700c?
Can you Change from a 30mm
What Do I Need for a
Pinarello FP3, Good for the Price?
Slipping Gear Problem

© 2008 BikeCyclingReviews.com